Skip to content

Pure criterion-referencing failed

One of the main things behind NCEA is that it is criterion-referenced — candidates are put against set standards rather than each other. But after three years, they’ve made a compromise already. The State Services Commission recommended the introduction of "safety nets" to ensure variation doesn’t get out of hand, but for there to be "tolerances" and to allow variation "where there is a defendable explanation". It is clear, then, that it has become accepted that pure criterion-referencing for academic fields will not work.

The introduction of NCEA was from one extreme to the other extreme on the norm-criterion referencing scale. The old exams were scaled so that the top student always got 96% and exactly half the country passed and half the country failed. The mark was, in effect, a ranking, not an indication of the candidate’s ability. Then NCEA went to the other end: there was to be no scaling whatsoever, only the comparison of a student’s work with set criteria.

The change was clearly a little bit too much. Any good system uses both norms and criteria. Either without the other will be meaningless.

The recommendation of the SSC is a fundamental shift in the assessment of NCEA. It is good that they allow tolerances and explanations, though — it is not such a drastic change in the sense that it is still designed to have standards remain consistent over time. But to allow scaling, the "artificial technique of ensuring a sufficient number of passes", as the NZ Herald editors put it, makes the results just that: artificial.

If all goes well, they shouldn’t have to use these safety nets to scale results. But this is another of NCEA’s reality checks. In the end, as politically correct and philosophically correct as it may seem, pure criterion-referencing without normative moderation won’t do.

Related Links

  • The State Services Commission report on the NZQA
  • Advertisements
    No comments yet

    Leave a comment

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

    You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

    Connecting to %s

    %d bloggers like this: